THE IMPACT OF VAPOR RECOVERY SYSTEMS

ATMOSPHERIC CHEMISTRY AND PHYSICS 52:163

PREPARED BY:

  • DIANA K. LOKENVITZ
  • JARROD HICKS
  • MARY SAWVEL

Vapor Recovery Systems are designed to capture vapors that would escape into the atmosphere as underground gas tanks and vehicles are being refueled. This web page will introduce Stage I and Stage II Vapor Recovery Systems and the effects that the released vapors have on the environment. The purpose of these systems is to reduce the emmisions of precursors to ozone in the troposphere.



WHAT IS OZONE?

Ozone is a gas that forms in the atmosphere when three atoms of oxygen are combined (O3). It is not emitted directly into the air, but at ground level is created by a chemical reaction between oxides of nitrogen (NOX), and volatile organic compounds (VOC) in the presence of sunlight. Ozone occurs in two layers in the atmosphere. The layer surrounding the Earth is the troposphere which extends to a level of about ten miles up, where it meets the second layer, the stratosphere. Tropospheric ozone is not desired because of several harmful effects on health, vegetation, and many common materials. However, stratospheric ozone is helpful in protecting life on Earth from the sun's harmful ultraviolet rays (UV-b).

The Ozone Profile
Courtesy of www.epa.gov/oar/oaqps/gooduphigh /#goodbad


STAGE I VAPOR RECOVERY SYSTEMS:

Stage I Vapor Recovery is used during the refueling of underground gasoline storage tanks found wherever gasoline is dispensed (for example: gas stations). Hydrocarbon vapors in the tank are displaced by the incoming gasoline and then routed through a hose into the cargo tanker instead of being vented into the atmosphere. The truck then takes the vapors back to the bulk terminal where they are either recovered or destroyed. This is all done in an attempt to reduce hydrocarbon emissions.

One type of Stage I Vapor Recovery is dual point. This system utilizes two openings, one to deliver the fuel, and the other to remove the vapor from the tank. Dual point systems are designed as either TOP or BOTTOM filling.

The second type of Stage I Vapor Recovery is the COAXIAL system. It requires only one opening from the tank. The system utilizes two tubes, one inside the other. The inner tube delivers the fuel while the vapor is removed through the outer tube.


STAGE II VAPOR RECOVERY SYSTEMS:

The purpose of the Stage II Vapor Recovery System is to capture vapors emitted as vehicles are being refueled. These systems contain special nozzle spouts that are used to collect the vapors, which are returned through the nozzle and hose back into the underground gasoline storage tank. Estimated cost for the fitting of nozzles for Stage II Vapor Recovery is approximately five hundred dollars per nozzle.

BELLOWLESS VACUUM- ASSIST SYSTEM
Vapor Recovery Nozzle
Courtesy of http://www.opw-fc.com/html/5501html

According to the EPA, properly maintained Stage II Vapor Recovery Systems reduce refueling vapors by approximately forty-one percent. These systems undergo rigorous tests including maintenance of: Air to Liquid Volume Ratio, Pressure Decay, and Dynamic Back-Pressure (Blockage). Diagrams of these three procedures follow. The first is the Air to Liquid Volume Ratio test. This test is straight-forward, it measures the ratio of air to liquid in the fuel. The second diagram shows the Pressure Decay test. This test procedure is used to quantify the tightness of Vapor Recovery systems installed at any gasoline dispensing facility equipped with pressure/vacuum (P/V) valves. The third diagram is of the Dynamic Back-Pressure test. This test procedure is used to quantify the Dynamic Pressure (Back-Pressure) in the vapor path leading from the dispensing nozzle to the storage tank.

AIR TO LIQUID VOLUME RATIO
Air to Liquid Volume Ratio Test
PRESSURE DECAY
Pressure Decay Test

DYNAMIC BACK- PRESSURE
Dynamic Back-Pressure Test
Courtesy of http://mtinternational.com/solu2.htm


EFFECTIVENESS OF VAPOR RECOVERY SYSTEMS

The following calculations are based on an annual throughput of one million gallons and include emissions from underground storage tank filling and vehicle refueling operations. Refueling emissions for Spokane County, Washington were used as a basis for the entire United States. These records were scaled up according to population to predict the annual national refueling emissions.

Facilities' total Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) emissions were reduced by 46% with Stage I Vapor Recovery Systems, 41% with Stage II Vapor Recovery Systems, and 87% with Stage I and Stage II.


BENEFITS OF VAPOR RECOVERY SYSTEMS

Vapor Recovery Systems help to minimize the production of O3 precursors, and in doing so, reduce the concentration of tropospheric ozone. This is beneficial since tropospheric ozone:

A second benefit of vapor recovery is the reduction of human exposure to gasoline fumes. These fumes contain over 150 chemicals, including benzene (very dangerous). Depending on the amount of gasoline fumes inhaled, and the sensitivity of the individual, gasoline can:


REFERENCES

http://www.epa/gov/oar/oaqps/gooduphigh/#goodbad

http://www.daq.state.nc-us/offices/Technical/Mobile/Vapor/

http://www.deq.co.pima.az.us/airinfo/stage2/stge2faq.html

http://www.scapca.org/gas.html

http://www.census.gov/population/www/estimates/popest.html

http://www.ideo.columbia.edu/~psguest/eda/ozone_/ecl.html


SITES THAT RELATE TO THIS STUFF

http://airq.ci.el-paso.tx.us/stageii4.htm

http://patent.womplex.ibm.com/details?patent_number=5345979

http://www.arb.ca.gov

http://www.deq.state.la.us/oarp/o3stage2.htm

http://www.dnr.state.mo.us/deq/apcp/stage1.htm#Quest


Last Updated 12/10/99